Product Filter

Best Selling Candy

  1. Home
  2. Best Selling Candy
  3. Peanut Butter
Filter by
Filter by

116 products found in Best Selling Candy

Quick View Reese's Peanut Butter Cups (Milk Chocolate) 1.5 OZ - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's Peanut Butter Cups (Milk Chocolate) 1.5 OZ
  • From $1.49
Quick View ZAGNUT BAR (PEANUT BUTTER/COCONUT) 1.5 oz Bar - Sweets and Geeks
ZAGNUT BAR (PEANUT BUTTER/COCONUT) 1.5 oz Bar
  • From $1.75
Quick View Boyer Jimmy Sticks 1.8 OZ - Sweets and Geeks
Boyer Jimmie Sticks 1.8 OZ
  • From $1.49
Quick View Reese's Peanut Butter Snack Cakes - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's Peanut Butter Snack Cakes 2.75oz
  • From $2.49
Quick View Reese's Big Cup Stuffed w/Potato Chips - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's Big Cup Stuffed w/Potato Chips 1.3 oz
  • From $1.49
Quick View CHICK-O-STICK NATURAL COUNTER BOX - 1.6 oz - Sweets and Geeks
CHICK-O-STICK NATURAL COUNTER BOX - 1.6 oz
  • From $1.49
Quick View Butterfinger 1.9oz - Sweets and Geeks
Butterfinger 1.9oz
  • From $1.49
Quick View Boyer Butterscotch Peanut Butter Cups 1.6 OZ - Sweets and Geeks
Boyer Butterscotch Peanut Butter Cups 1.6 OZ
  • From $1.49

Sold out

Quick View Reese's Nutrageous Bar 1.66 OZ - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's Nutrageous Bar 1.66 OZ
  • From $1.49
Quick View Reese's Big Cup W/ Reese's Puffs 1.2oz- King Size - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's Big Cup W/ Reese's Puffs 2.40oz- King Size
  • From $2.49
Quick View Reese's Sticks 1.5oz - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's Sticks 1.5oz
  • From $1.49
Quick View Reese's XL 4.25OZ Chocolate Bar - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's XL 4.25OZ Chocolate Bar
  • From $2.99
Quick View M&M Peanut Butter Share Size Bag - Sweets and Geeks
M&M Peanut Butter Share Size Bag 2oz
  • From $2.49
Quick View Whozeewhatzit King Size Candy Bars - Sweets and Geeks
Whozeewhatzit King Size Candy Bars Chocolate 2.6oz
  • From $2.49
Quick View Reese's Pieces 1.53 oz - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's Pieces 1.53 oz
  • From $1.49
Quick View REESES PIECES THEATER BOX - Sweets and Geeks
REESES PIECES THEATER BOX 4oz
  • From $1.99
Quick View Abba-Zaba Bars - Sweets and Geeks
Abba-Zaba Bars 1.8oz
  • From $1.99
Quick View Reese's Fast Break King Size Bar 3.5oz - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's Fast Break King Size Bar 3.5oz
  • From $2.49
Quick View Goo Goo: Peanut Butter Cluster 1.5OZ - Sweets and Geeks
Goo Goo: Peanut Butter Cluster 1.5OZ
  • From $2.49

Sold out

Quick View Reese's Big Cup With Pretzels 1.3 oz - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's Big Cup With Pretzels 1.3 oz
  • From $1.49
Quick View Reese's Giant Peanut Butter Bar 7.37oz - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's Giant Peanut Butter Bar 7.37oz
  • From $3.99
Quick View Reese's Big Cup W/ Reese's Pieces King Size 2.8oz - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's Big Cup W/ Reese's Pieces King Size 2.8oz
  • From $2.49
Quick View M&M Peanut Butter - Sweets and Geeks
M&M Peanut Butter 1.6oz Bag
  • From $1.49
Quick View Whozeewhatzit Candy Bars - Sweets and Geeks
Whozeewhatzit Candy Bars
  • From $1.99
Quick View Snickers Peanut Butter Squares 4 To Go Share Size - Sweets and Geeks
Snickers Peanut Butter Squares 4 To Go Share Size 4oz
  • From $2.99

Sold out

Quick View Reese's "Chrunchy" Snack Cakes - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's "Crunchy" Snack Cakes 2.75oz
  • From $2.49
Quick View Snickers Peanut Butter Squared - Sweets and Geeks
Snickers Peanut Butter Squared 1.78oz
  • From $1.49
Quick View Hammond's Peanut Butter Cup - Dark - Sweets and Geeks
Hammond's Peanut Butter Cup - Dark 2.25oz
  • From $3.99