Product Filter

Best Selling Candy

  1. Home
  2. Best Selling Candy
  3. Peanut Butter
Filter by
Filter by

117 products found in Best Selling Candy

Sold out

Quick View Reese's Heart Box 5oz - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's Heart Box 5oz
  • $5.99
Quick View M&M's Xmas Peanut Butter 10oz - Sweets and Geeks
M&M's Xmas Peanut Butter 10oz
  • $5.99

Sold out

Quick View Reese's Peanut Butter Bunny 4.25oz - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's Peanut Butter Bunny 4.25oz
  • $7.99

Sold out

Quick View Reese's Super Giant Peanut Butter Cups - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's Super Giant Peanut Butter Cups
  • $16.99
Quick View
Reese's Big Cup King Size 2.8oz
  • From $1.99
Quick View Gurley's Crunchy Peanut Butter Bar 2.5oz - Sweets and Geeks
Gurley's Crunchy Peanut Butter Bar 2.5oz
  • From $1.00

Sold out

Quick View Reese's Valentine Roses 3.9oz - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's Valentine Roses 3.9oz
  • $4.99

Sold out

Quick View Reese's Halloween Miniature Peanut Butter Cup 9.92oz - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's Halloween Miniature Peanut Butter Cup 9.92oz
  • $6.99

Sold out

Quick View Reese's Peanut Butter Cups Valentine Heart Gift Box 6.5oz - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's Peanut Butter Cups Valentine Heart Gift Box 6.5oz
  • $6.99
Quick View
Butterfinger Unwrapped Minis 8oz Stand Up Bag
  • From $4.49

Sold out

Quick View Chick-O-Stick 48ct Bag - Sweets and Geeks
Chick-O-Stick 48ct Bag
  • From $7.99
Quick View M&M's Peanuts Valentines Pouch 10oz - Sweets and Geeks
M&M's Peanuts Valentines Pouch 10oz
  • $5.99
Quick View
CHICK-O-STICK NATURAL COUNTER BOX Change maker
  • From $0.33
Quick View
Reese's Nutrageous Bar King Size 3.1oz
  • From $2.49

Sold out

Quick View Reese's Miniature Cups Candy Cane 6oz - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's Miniature Cups Candy Cane 6oz
  • $6.99

Sold out

Quick View Abba-Zaba Mini 10oz Bags - Sweets and Geeks
Abba-Zaba Mini 10oz Bags
  • $6.99

Sold out

Quick View Reese's Sports Ball Tins 2.4oz - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's Sports Ball Tins 2.4oz
  • $5.49
Quick View
Reese's Chocolate Lava Big Cup King Size 2.8oz
  • From $2.99
Quick View
Reese's Pieces King Size 3oz
  • From $2.49
Quick View
Reese's Chocolate Lava Big Cup 1.4oz
  • From $1.99

Sold out

Quick View Reese's Peanut Butter Egg 6oz - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's Peanut Butter Egg 6oz
  • $8.99
Quick View
Dible Dough Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough 1.6oz Bar
  • From $3.99

Sold out

Quick View
Chocolove Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups 0.6oz
  • From $1.49

Sold out

Quick View Reese's Peanut Butter Eggs 6 Count Tray 7.2oz - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's Peanut Butter Eggs 6 Count Tray 7.2oz
  • $8.99

Sold out

Quick View M&M's Xmas Peanut Butter 34oz - Sweets and Geeks
M&M's Xmas Peanut Butter 34oz
  • $19.99

Sold out

Quick View Reese's Peanut Butter Hearts Gift Box 6.5oz - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's Peanut Butter Hearts Gift Box 6.5oz
  • $6.99

Sold out

Quick View Reese's Lovers Advent Calander 3.8oz - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's Lovers Advent Calander 3.8oz
  • $7.99

Sold out

Quick View Taffy Town PB&J 2.5lbs Bag - Sweets and Geeks
Taffy Town Peanut Butter and Jelly 2.5lbs Bag
  • $12.99